A Note on Tobacco Reviews

[Alex]

Love to see Father Tom's reviews
/quote]

I would like to read them too how do I find them ?

[Armycw2]

Why I don't do reviews. To me a smoke is either OK, Meh, I can smoke it or Yuck. That covers all the bases of what I have tried so far.

Agreed . If someone has similar likes and says is great , good or crap .. I pay attention . The last thing I'd want to listen to is some latakia bomb lover who hates aromatics give an aromatic review , as an example

That drives me crazy too...if you dont like aromatics dont review them.

[Fr_Tom]

I would like to read them too how do I find them ?

https://www.tobaccoreviews.com/user/14371

[Citizen B]

Love to see Father Tom's reviews
/quote]

I would like to read them too how do I find them ?

https://www.tobaccoreviews.com/user/14371

Be careful what you wish for, @Middle Earth .

[Alex]

I would like to read them too how do I find them ?

https://www.tobaccoreviews.com/user/14371

Thank you father , for the link.
I am interested in "old companion"by H&H ,is it still your go to ?

[Fr_Tom]

I would like to read them too how do I find them ?

https://www.tobaccoreviews.com/user/14371

Thank you father , for the link.
I am interested in "old companion"by H&H ,is it still your go to ?

They quit making it. I really enjoyed it.

[Alex]

https://www.tobaccoreviews.com/user/14371

Be careful what you wish for, @Middle Earth .

You mean God's. Priest's, (good ones ) don't judge, nor can they.

[Alex]

https://www.tobaccoreviews.com/user/14371

Thank you father , for the link.
I am interested in "old companion"by H&H ,is it still your go to ?

They quit making it. I really enjoyed it.

That's too bad , They keep doing that ,don't they .Just when I find some tobacco that sound like a new positive experience to me it's gone . It would be nice to have a a solid easy-going go to. But maybe there isn't really such thing.

[Citizen B]

Be careful what you wish for, @Middle Earth .

You mean God's. Priest's, (good ones ) don't judge, nor can they.

I don't think I wrote that. It doesn't sound like me, though it is a true statement.

[Puff nstuff]

There used to be a theory that the more "gym laundry" the tin note, the better the smoke.

I always called it barnyard. And the more a cigar smelled that way, the better it was!

Haha. This is somewhat akin to a term that a friend and I occasionally use when we're describing the odor/flavor of some red wines that we like, typically Spanish or French. When essence of barnyard becomes wetter and heavier, we call it 'duck butt.' If it's got duck butt going, there's a strong funk going on that we typically appreciate if it hasn't completely taken over the overall flavor profile.

I find reading reviews of tobacco (and wine, and beer, and bourbon) enjoyable, not only for the information I may glean from them, but for the creative language often used to describe the oh-so-nuanced flavor and texture perceptions.